Strandbeest Optimizer for LEGO

LEGO Strandbeest Optimizer

A LEGO Approximation of Strandbeest

Posted by Wade Vagle

This simulator allows you to quickly check how changing Strandbeest's bar lengths affect its foot-path, but remember, just because something looks good in a simulation doesn't necessarily mean it will work well when built - at least not without some tinkering, such as managing possible dead-points (see below).

Here's a video of the simulator in action, and the embedded simulator can be found below.

Below are Jansen's linkage and a LEGO approximation, scaled so that the crank=3:

Jansen's Linkage Scaled so the Crank=3, and a LEGO Approximation

And below are Jansen's linkage measurements along with the LEGO approximation. Note: this LEGO approximation uses the 7x3 bent beam pictured on the right for Bar 8 (B8).

Length of a LEGO 7x3 bent beam = 7.38

Strandbeest's linkage dimensions scaled so that the crank=3, and a LEGO approximation

When building a simulated linkage in LEGO, remember to use beams with one more hole than the bar's length. For example, a bar of length 8 requires a LEGO beam with 9 holes, because when determining the length of LEGO beams, the first hole is always counted as zero.

LEGO hole counts of an approximation of Strandbeest

Here's a LEGO build of this configuration in action:

Strandbeest's frame coordinates, and a LEGO approximation

As you can see in the above images, the "LowFrame" variables are the distances from frame connection #2 to the center of the crank.

Below are the foot-paths of both versions, as well as the speed of the feet when in contact with the ground (assuming 8 legs, not 12).

Notice how Strandbeest's horizontal foot-speed slows at both ends of the foot-path, which can cause Strandbeest to have a halting gait on higher friction terrain. This can be mitigated with feet that slide or rotate, as shown in this experiment.

Strandbeest's speed and turning can be smoothed with feet that slide or rotate

Also, notice in the video below how Strandbeest's forward speed drops or reverses when the ground height changes, which is due to the triangular shape of its foot-path. This is further explored in this walking tanks post.

A description of the algorithms, and how we used them to simulate Strandbeest's linkage, is here.

We tested this LEGO approximation with the heavy EV3 brick, which walked well on smooth surfaces, but needed rotating feet for carpeting - the leverage of its long legs put too much force on them when turning.

Below is the embedded simulator. You can also run the simulator on MIT's site where you can modify the Scratch code. A description of the algorithms used in this Jansen linkage calculator is here.

After changing a bar's length, click somewhere other than a slider bar and then press the space bar to see the new linkage and foot-path, and use your keyboard's left/right arrows to rotate the crank. To choose Strandbeest's bar lengths click "Jansen" then press the space bar.

Jansen Linkage Calculator

Below is another LEGO option with a higher, but shorter foot-path. Notice the X-value of the leg's lower frame connection #2 is one hole further from the crank ("LowFrameX" is increased from 8 to 9). You can see an example leg built with these dimensions in LEGO below.

A LEGO Approximation of Strandbeest

Foot-Paths and Speed of Strandbeest and a LEGO Approximation with a Shorter Foot-Path

Below is an example of how to build the legs of this shorter foot-path approximation of Strandbeest in LEGO. This configuration may work as an 8-leg, steerable Strandbeest, but it will need to be tested, and may require some tinkering. The long legs would provide plenty of room beneath the frame to mount either LEGO's battery box or EV3 brick, like with this long-legged Klann walker. But, as shown in the above Mindstorms Strandbeest video, EV3 versions may need either smooth surfaces, or rotating/sliding feet.

A LEGO Approximation of Strandbeest

As shown below, Strandbeest's knee joint may tend to "flip" at its Dead Point:

As shown below, to build straight legs that don't bind or jam, make sure leg parts connect to parts in an adjacent plane

Front View

Top View

Other LEGO-Friendly Possibilities for Strandbeest

Below are a few more possibilities for approximating Strandbeest in LEGO with only using straight Technic beams. You may be able to find better approximations if you include more of LEGO's bent beams in your optimization (lengths below).

Strandbeest's Linkage Dimensions Scaled so the Crank=3

LEGO Ver 0

LEGO Ver 1

LEGO Ver 2

LEGO Ver 3

This high-step version 5 to the right probably wouldn't work well with the abrupt bending of the knee, which you can better see in the below images as well as in the above video. Plus, the leg parts may collide.

LEGO Ver 4

LEGO Ver 5?

Knee bend of LEGO Ver 5

Of the above LEGO approximations of Strandbeest, Ver 3 has the most consistent foot-speed, but it doesn't step as high:

Jansen's Linkage Scaled so the Crank=3, and a LEGO Approximation (Ver 3)

There are likely better LEGO-friendly versions of Strandbeest that can be found with the simulator, especially if LEGO's bent bars are included in the search. Note: more odd-length beams can be created by extending the below beams with straight beams, and plugging the side lengths and angle into the Law of Cosines to calculate the new distances. UPDATE: MIT released Scratch 3.0 on Jan 1, 2019, which currently doesn't allow variables to be set above 100 with the slider bar, nor decimals, meaning these odd-length bars have to be put in the simulator's code on MIT's site - for now at least.

Lengths of LEGO's bent beams

A description of the algorithms, and how we used them to simulate Strandbeest's linkage, is here.